LCQ15: Transport support facilities and planning for Sai Sha, Shap Sz Heung
***************************************************************

     â€‹Following is a question by the Hon Chan Hak-kan and a written reply by the Secretary for Transport and Logistics, Ms Mable Chan, in the Legislative Council today (November 18):

Question:

     The residential units and facilities in the various phases of the large-scale comprehensive development project at Sai Sha are being completed and occupied in succession. Together with the long-standing villages in the vicinity, the future population of the area may approach 30 000, which will pose a severe test to the overall transport network both within and outside the area. In this connection, will the Government inform this Council:

(1) given that the Shap Sz Heung development project is expected to bring about a massive increase in population, whether the Government will consider extending the Tuen Ma Line eastwards from the existing Wu Kai Sha Station to the Nai Chung and Sai Sha areas, so as to enable railway transport to play its role as the backbone of the public transport system and thereby divert road traffic load at source; if so, of the details; if not, the reasons for that;

(2) whether the Government can provide data on the design capacity and actual traffic flow of Sai Sha Road upon completion of its widening works, as well as the estimated traffic flow and peak-hour load of Sai Sha Road upon full population intake of the aforesaid development project;

(3) whether, apart from local distributor roads, the Government has assessed the traffic load to be imposed on external primary distributor roads connecting the area with the urban areas (including Ma On Shan Road and Tate's Cairn Highway) upon full intake of the additional population in the aforesaid area; of the current design flow, actual usage volume and projected future peak-hour volume/capacity ratio of those roads respectively;

(4) given that there is currently a service gap in the coverage hours of public transport services at the Sai Sha Residences Transport Interchange between 5.30am and 6.20am, which cannot meet residents' needs for early-morning commuting to work and school, whether the Government will urge franchised bus operators to increase the number of early-morning departures or advance the departure time of the first departures; if so, of the details and the implementation timetable; if not, the reasons for that; and

(5) whether, apart from the existing housing projects, the Government has undertaken any longer-term overall land use and development planning for Shap Sz Heung and its neighbouring areas; if so, of the details; if not, the reasons for that?

Reply:

President, 
     
     The Government has been closely monitoring the road network and traffic conditions across various districts and will carry out traffic management and road improvement works in a timely manner, having regard to the actual traffic flow and local development needs. Having consulted the Development Bureau, the reply to the Member's question is as follows: 

(1) During the planning application for the Shap Sz Heung development in Sai Kung, the relevant developer has already conducted a detailed traffic impact assessment in respect of the development scale of the project and the additional traffic flow arising from the development. Based on the assessment results, the developer implemented a series of traffic improvement works, including widening the section of Sai Sha Road between Sai O Village and Tai Tung Tsuen, as well as other related measures to cater for the additional traffic demand arising from the development.

     Taking forward railway transport infrastructure projects requires significant resources, and factors such as technical feasibility and cost-effectiveness have to be considered in a prudent manner. Regarding the suggestion of extending the Tuen Ma Line eastwards from the existing Wu Kai Sha Station to the Nai Chung and Sai Sha areas, having preliminarily reviewed factors such as its transport benefits, service catchment and engineering technology, the Government currently has no plan to extend the Tuen Ma Line eastwards to the Nai Chung and Sai Sha areas.

(2) and (3) At present, the traffic flow of Sai Sha Road urban-bound during the morning peak hours (i.e. from 7.30am to 8.30am on weekdays) is about 1 200 passenger car units per hour (pcu/hr).

     To cope with the traffic demand arising from the Sai Sha comprehensive development project, the developer has widened a 1.5 km section of Sai Sha Road from a single two-lane undivided carriageway with only one lane in eastbound and westbound direction each, to a dual carriageway with two lanes in each direction. Correspondingly, the road capacity has been upgraded from approximately 1 200 pcu/hr per direction to around 3 400 pcu/hr per direction. As a result, the existing volume-to-capacity (V/C) ratio is about 0.35. According to the traffic impact assessment for the development project, upon completion of the project, the morning peak hours traffic flow along Sai Sha Road urban-bound is estimated to be around 2 100 pcu/hr, with a V/C ratio of about 0.62, indicating that the road still has sufficient spare capacity.

     The primary trunk roads connecting Sai Sha to the urban areas are Ma On Shan Road and Tate's Cairn Highway. Although traffic toward the urban areas during weekday morning peak hours is quite heavy, it remains generally capable of meeting traffic demands. The Transport Department (TD) has been closely monitoring the traffic conditions in the vicinity of Sai Sha Road and the primary external trunk roads, and is also aware of the new developments in nearby areas (such as the Pak Shek Kok Station and its associated Ma On Shan land development project). Relevant projects are required to comprehensively assess their traffic impacts on the area's trunk roads. The Government will work with the developers in a timely manner to formulate and implement appropriate traffic improvement measures in order to ensure the road network will be able to cater for future traffic demand.

(4) Currently, Green Minibus Route No. 807K in the New Territories provides services between Tseng Tau (via Shap Sz Heung Development Project) and University Station from 5.45am to 12.15am daily, with a frequency of every six to 15 minutes. In late September this year, the TD conducted an onsite survey at an intermediate stop at Hoi Ying Road along the route, which passes through the Shap Sz Heung Development Project. The results showed that from the first departure of the day until 7am, the occupancy rate of the trips from Tseng Tau to University Station ranged from approximately 20 per cent to 90 per cent upon arrival at that intermediate stop, with no instances of passengers being unable to board, indicating that the route can meet the needs of local residents travelling to and from the railway station during that period. The TD will continue to closely monitor the population intake of the Shap Sz Heung Development Project and changes in passenger demand and will work with public transport operators to explore the feasibility of enhancing services in a timely manner.

(5) The Shap Sz Heung area is mainly covered by the approved Shap Sz Heung Outline Zoning Plan (OZP) No. S/NE-SSH/11. As Shap Sz Heung is predominantly rural in character and rich in natural resources, the planning intention is primarily to preserve sites of visual, ecological and geological significance, and to identify areas with development potential for private residential and recreational uses, ensuring that all developments are compatible with the surrounding rural and natural environment. The majority of the land (about 70 per cent) covered by the Shap Sz Heung OZP is zoned as "Conservation Area" (CA), "Site of Special Scientific Interest" (SSSI), "Coastal Protection Area", "Green Belt" (GB) and "Village Type Development" (V), all of which are not suitable for large-scale development. As for the land on the Shap Sz Heung OZP suitable for more sizeable development, most of it has been zoned as "Comprehensive Development Area" (CDA). Within the "CDA" zone, commercial and recreational facilities have largely been completed, while residential developments are being completed in phases.

     The area adjacent to Shap Sz Heung, including the Nai Chung/Cheung Muk Tau area to the west of Shap Sz Heung along Sai Sha Road, is covered by the approved Ma On Shan OZP No. S/MOS/28, which is situated on the outskirts of Ma On Shan New Town. Apart from areas zoned "V", "Residential (Group C)" for low-density developments, and "Government, Institution or Community", the majority of area is zoned "GB", "CA" and "SSSI", in order to preserve the natural landscape with ecological and geological values. Among the land in Nai Chung/Cheung Muk Tau suitable for sizable development, the major project is the Cheung Muk Tau public housing development currently under construction.

     With regard to the land use of Shap Sz Heung and its surrounding areas, the Planning Department considers that the aforesaid planning intention remains applicable and has struck a balance between the needs for development and conservation.

Ends/Wednesday, November 18, 2026
Issued at HKT 14:48

NNNN