LCQ5: Out-of-service incident of parking meter system
*****************************************************

     Following is a question by the Hon Aaron Bok and a reply by the Secretary for Transport and Logistics, Ms Mable Chan, in the Legislative Council today (November 18):

Question:

     In the morning of November 3, 2026, the parking meter system of the Transport Department was out of service, whereby services in multiple districts were affected. In this connection, will the Government inform this Council:

(1) regarding the above incident, whether the Government has thoroughly identified the root cause of the out-of-service incident, such as by looking into the backend central system, network transmission or software update, and of the follow-up actions to be taken; whether the existing smart meters rely excessively on a single central backend or network node such that a single point of failure leads to disabling of the system; whether the Government will arrange an independent technical review to evaluate system resilience;

(2) of the specific indicators for service availability, incident notification time frame and restoration performance under the existing contracts for operation and maintenance of the parking meter system; whether there are improvement plans triggered upon service disruption, terms for continuous optimisation or service performance adjustment mechanisms; and

(3) whether the Government will make a horizontal comparison of the parking meter system with the critical systems for smart city, such as smart lampposts, traffic control and surveillance systems, to examine if there are similar risks of single-point failure, lack of fault isolation or switch-over mechanism to backup system; and whether it will establish standardised benchmarks for evaluating system resilience and include "system architecture redundancy" and "incident recovery capability" as core performance indicators in contracts signed in the future?

Reply:

President,

     The Government attaches great importance to the malfunction incident of the on-street metered parking system of the Transport Department (TD) on the morning of November 3, 2026. Following the malfunction of the system in that morning, the TD immediately instructed the operator to restore the system as soon as possible, and sternly required the operator to conduct a thorough investigation into the cause of the incident and submit a report.

     The reply to the question raised by the Member is as follows:

(1) After jointly reviewing the incident report submitted by the operator, the TD, the Electrical and Mechanical Services Department (EMSD) and the Digital Policy Office (DPO) discovered that the incident was caused by a software update on the system carried out by the operator on the early morning of November 3. The new version of the software programme was defective, preventing the backend system from connecting properly to the parking meters. The TD confirmed with the operator, the EMSD and the DPO that the incident was not attributable to hardware failure, transmission disruption resulting from vandalism, or hacking attacks, nor did it involve any personal or payment data leakage.

     Currently, the backend system, which is connected to about 11 000 parking meters across the territory, comprises two server centres responsible for the parking meters in the urban areas (Hong Kong Island and Kowloon) and the New Territories respectively. After the incident, the operator immediately performed troubleshooting and took remedial actions. Upon emergency repair, the vast majority of the parking meters gradually resumed normal operation from 10.45am on November 3, the day of the incident, and full resumption of normal operation was confirmed at 12.10pm. To ensure the smooth operation of the system, the operator has strengthened its routine real-time monitoring and undertaken daily system health checks. Moreover, the TD has all along commissioned an independent professional third-party organisation to conduct an all-round Security Risk Assessment and Audit (SRAA) covering the entire system, applications, infrastructure and the operational procedures after consulting the EMSD. The TD will carry out the next round of comprehensive SRAA in December 2026.

(2) The existing executed contract between the Government and the system operator sets out a comprehensive service level agreement, which specifies the requirements for the operator's daily operations, malfunction reporting, restoration timeframe and service performance, including an overall service availability of 99 per cent or above for the parking meters, expeditious reporting of major incidents as soon as practicable within 15 minutes and arrival at the scene within 45 minutes, as well as completion of repairing damaged parking meters within three hours of the incident and restoration of the affected system and other components within 24 hours. In the event of system service disruption, the operator is required not only to report the matter, but also to strengthen its hotline manpower to handle public enquiries, and to submit an incident report and proposal for enhancement measures.

     To monitor the service level of the operator and encourage the operator's continuous enhancement, the TD regularly evaluates the performance and service effectiveness of the operator. If the operator is found to fail in providing services in compliance with the contractual provisions, the TD will impose corresponding penalties, including verbal and written warnings, and even financial penalties. At the request of the TD, the operator has arranged to refund the parking meter fees paid by the users during the incident and will compensate the Government regarding the incident. Taking into account of the incident duration, the operator has committed an indemnity of about $1.3 million to the Government.

     To prevent recurrence of malfunction, the TD has collaborated with the EMSD to holistically review the system engineering design and modify the management procedures. The DPO is also involved to provide technical advice. The TD has instructed the operator to implement various measures to step up system monitoring, stringently gatekeep software updates, and introduce high-intensity load tests. The operator has committed to conducting high-intensity load tests in a staging environment that simulates actual operating conditions before rolling out future updates to the system, and exploring the implementation of updates in phases by starting with small-scale trials before proceeding to full implementation, with a view to fostering the resilience of the system at its root.

(3) The Government attaches great importance to the security, stability and resilience of information systems. To this end, the DPO has been providing departments with policy guidelines and technical standards for the operation, maintenance and governance of information systems, covering requirements on project management, system design, system development and testing, system maintenance, information technology (IT) security, system resilience, etc. Departments make reference to relevant guidelines and standards when preparing tender and contract arrangements for IT systems, and implement and manage their IT projects after considering factors including relevant policies, service users, demand for e-services, system operation and resilience, etc.

     The TD's major systems operate independently. Daily traffic monitoring and management are performed using information provided by various systems. The TD, relevant departments and operators monitor the operation of different systems, and each system is equipped with regular monitoring and real-time alert measures, covering hardware conditions, network connections, data and communication volume, system usage, and system maintenance, etc, to enable the relevant departments and operators to detect anomalies in time, thereby promptly handle and respond to the situation. In response to this incident, the TD has reminded the operators of relevant systems to diligently gatekeep software updates, and all-round testing must be conducted before rolling out new systems in actual environment.

     Besides, as regards the smart lamppost project co-ordinated by the DPO, it primarily supports departments in installing and adopting suitable smart devices and sensors according to their operational needs. The smart lampposts and related smart devices operate independently. A failure in an individual lamppost or device generally does not affect the normal operation of other smart lampposts and devices.

     Thank you, President.

Ends/Wednesday, November 18, 2026
Issued at HKT 14:58

NNNN