Our Ref. :

B1/1C
B9/67C

25 February 2008

The Chief Executive
All Authorized Institutions

Dear Sir/Madam,

Complaints Against Debt Collection Agents Employed by Authorized Institutions

I write to inform you of the results of the industry survey on complaints against debt collection agents (DCAs) employed by authorized institutions (AIs) for the fourth quarter of 2007.  Please see the Annex for details. 

During the reporting period, 39 AIs used the services of DCAs.  They together assigned 73,087 accounts to 23 DCAs.

A total of 21 complaints against 11 DCAs were received by 11 AIs (compared with 25 complaints against 10 DCAs received by 12 AIs in the previous quarter).  The incidence of complaints per 1,000 accounts assigned was 0.29 compared with 0.31 in the previous quarter.  As in the previous quarter, no complaints were lodged by unrelated third parties.

One instance of a breach of the Code of Banking Practice was reported during the quarter compared to nil in the previous quarter. In this case, the debt collector misled the complainant to believe that he was a staff member of the lending AI, and allegedly disclosed the loan details of the debtor to his colleagues (although this could not be confirmed because of a malfunction in the telephone recording system of the DCA on the day in question).  The AI issued a warning letter to the DCA in light of the incident. It also required the DCA to develop a proper business continuity plan to ensure that its telephone recording system works at all times.

 

Yours faithfully,

 

Karen Kemp
Executive Director (Banking Policy)

 

c.c.

The Chairman, Hong Kong Association of Banks
The Chairman, The DTC Association
Secretary, Code of Banking Practice Committee (Attn: Ms Eva Wong – HKAB)
Secretary for Financial Services and the Treasury (Attn: Mr Parson Lam)

 

Annex

Survey on DCA complaints received by AIs - Q4/2007

Table 1: AIs using DCA service

 

Q4/2007

Q3/2007

Q2/2007

Q1/2007

Q4/2006

AIs receiving DCA complaints

11

12

10

13

10

AIs receiving no DCA complaints

28

27

29

27

32

Total

39

39

39

40

42

 

Table 2: Number of DCAs employed by AIs

 

Q4/2007

Q3/2007

Q2/2007

Q1/2007

Q4/2006

1 – 5

22

21

21

21

22

6 – 10

14

15

15

16

17

11 – 15

3

3

3

3

3

Total

39

39

39

40

42

 

Table 3: Incidence of DCA complaints

 

Q4/2007

Q3/2007

Q2/2007

Q1/2007

Q4/2006

DCA complaints received (A)

21

25

26

31

28

Accounts assigned (B) 

73,087

80,557

78,471

76,537

72,062

Incidence of complaints per 1,000 accounts (C = A/B x 1,000)

0.29

0.31

0.33

0.41

0.39

 

Table 4: Status of complainants

 

Q4/2007

Q3/2007

Q2/2007

Q1/2007

Q4/2006

Debtors

17

18

19

20

20

Family members/friends

3

7

3

5

4

Referees

1

0

0

0

1

Unrelated third parties

0

0

4

6

3

Total

21

25

26

31

28

 

 

Back to Top