
¡¯¡¯¡¯¡¯¡¯¡¯¡¯¡¯¡¯¡¯¡¯¡¯¡¯¡¯¡¯¡¯¡¯¡¯¡¯¡¯¡¯¡¯¡¯¡¯¡¯¡¯¡¯¡¯¡¯¡¯
¡@¡@¥H¤U¬O¦D¨ÆÀ˱±±Mû·¨®a¶¯¸ê²`¤j«ß®v¤µ¤é¡]¥|¤ë¤G¤Q¤K¤é¡^¦b¥ßªk·|¸gÀÙµo®i¨Æ°È©eû·|·|ijªº¶}³õµo¨¥¡G
¥D®u¡J
¡@¡@«ß¬F¥q²z¸Ñ®üÃøªÌ®aÄݪº·P¨ü¡A¥ç©ú¥Õ¥L̤Τ½²³´Á±æª¾¹D¤p²Õ½Õ¬dªºµ²ªG¡C¦Ó¥¿¥¿´N¬O¦]¬°§Ú̦P¼Ë§Æ±æ¯à±o±x¨Æ¥óªº¯u¬Û¡A¦n¥O¤½¸q³Ì²×¯à³z¹L§Ú̪ºªk«ß¤Î¥qªk¨î«×±o¥HªÃ¦æ¡A«ß¬F¥q¦b³B²z¦p¦ó¤Î¦ó®É¤½¶}¤p²Õªº½Õ¬d³ø§i®É¡A§ó¶·¯S§O¤p¤ß¡C±ý³t¤£¹F¡A«áªG§ó¥i¯à¾A±o¨ä¤Ï¡C«ß¬F¥q¤£«ØÄ³²{¶¥¬q¤½¶}½Õ¬d³ø§iªº¥þ³¡¤º®e¡A¬O°ò©ó´XÓì¦]¡C·í¤¤¤@Ó¥D¦]¡A¬O«ß¬F¥q»{¬°²{¶¥¬q¥þ±¤½¶}½Õ¬d³ø§i¤º®e¡A¦³ÄY«ªº·ÀI¼vÅT¬ÛÃöªº¦D¨Æ½Õ¬d¤Î¥i¯à·|¶i¦æªº¥ô¦ó¦D¨Æµ{§Ç¡C§Ú§Æ±æ±q¦D¨ÆÀ˱±ªº¨¤«×¡A´N³oì¦]¦V©eû·|¸ÑÄÀ¡C
¡@¡@§Úº¥ý±j½Õ¤TÂI¡G
¡]1¡^«ß¬F¥q³o·N¨£¯Âºé¬O°ò©óªk«ß¦Ò¼{¡C
i.¡@¦b»´ä¡A¥ô¦ó¤H¨ü¦D¨Æ±±§i¡A§¡¦³Åv¨üªk®x¤½¥¿¤½¶}¼f°T¡C³oÅv§Q¨ü¡m°ò¥»ªk¡n«O»Ù¡F
ii.¡@®e³\§Ú¤Þ¥Î¤G¡³¡³¤@¦~»´ä²×¼fªk°|»´ä¯S°Ï¶D§õ©úªv³o®×¨Ò¡]2001¡^4 HKCFAR 133¡F
iii.¡@¤@¤E¤E¤G¦~¡A·í®É°]¬F¥q¦]ÃhºÃ¬Y¤W¥«¤½¥q¯A¤Î¤@¨Ç¹H³W¦æ¬°¡A¨M©w¤Þ¥Î¡m¤½¥q±ø¨Ò¡n¡A©e¥ô¤@¦W¼f¬dû½Õ¬d¦³Ãö¦æ¬°¡C½Õ¬d³ø§i¦b¤@¤E¤E¤T¦~§¹¦¨¡C¦P¦~¤E¤ë¡A°]¬F¥q¨M©w±N³ø§iªº ç¸`ª©¤½¶}¡F
iv.¡@¦³Ãö³Q§i¦b¤@¤E¤E¤C¦Ü¤@¤E¤E¤K¦~¶¡³Q®·¡A®×¥ó¦b¤G¡³¡³¡³¦~¥|¤ë¶}¼f¡F
v.¡@³Q¤½¶}ªº½Õ¬d³ø§iÁö¬O ç¸`ª©¡A¦ý¤´ª½±µÄ²¤Î³Q§i«á¨Ó±¹ïªº±±¸o¡A¨Ã³Q¼sªx³ø¹D¡C¯S§O¡A³ø§iªº ç¸`ª©¤½¶}¤F¼f¬dû¦b½Õ¬d´Á¶¡·j¶°¤Î¦Ò¼{¹Lªº¸ê®Æ¤ÎÃÒ¾Ú¡A¤Î¥L»{¬°³Q§i¤H¯A¤Î¹H¤Ï¦Dªk¦æ¬°³oµ²½×¡F
vi.¡@°ò©ó¤Wz¤Î¨ä¥L²z¾Ú¡A³Q§iÅGºÙ¥L̤£·|±o¨ì¤½¥¿ªº¼f°T¡A¥Ó½Ð±N¼f°T¥Ã¤[ÀÁ¸m¡Cì¼fªk©xÅ¥¨ú©Ò¦³²z¾Ú«á¡A¦P·N¨Ã¹{¥O¥Ã¤[ÀÁ¸m¦³Ãö¼f°T¡F
vii.¡@¨ä«á¡A¸g¹L¦~¦h§éÄË¡A±±¤è³Ì²×¤W¶D¦Ü²×¼fªk°|¡C²×¼fªk°|¦b¦Ò¼{©Ò¦³¬ÛÃö¦]¯À¡A³Ì²×µô©w®×¤¤³Q§i¤´¥i±o¨ì¤½¥¿ªº¼f°T¡CÁöµM¦p¦¹¡A²×¼fªk°|¤´ÄYµü«ü¥X¡A¦³Ãö³ø§i¤£À³¦b¦D¨Æµ{§Ç§¹µ²«e¤½¶}¡C²×¼fªk°|¦³Ãöªº§PµüªºÂ½Ä¶¥»¦p¤U¡G
¡@¡@¡u¤@¦W°]¬F¥q©úª¾¦³À˱±¥´ºâ¡A¦ý¤´¥Ì«_·l®`¼f°T¤§ÀI¡A¤Oª§µoªí³ø§i¤Î¥l¶}°OªÌ©Û«Ý·|¤½¶}³ø§i¡A¦p´µ±¡´º¡A°Z´±®¥ºû¡I¡K¡K¤O¨¥³o¦³§U´£°ª¬F©²³z©ú«×¡A¤@©w¸g¤£°_¦ÒÅç¡C´£°ª³z©ú«×®í³ôºÙ¹D¡A¦ý¨S¦³¤H¥i¥H²zª½®ð§§¦a´£¥X¡A§Y¨Ï¹ï©ó±¹ïÄY«±±¸oªº¤H¡A³o¼Ë°µ·|¦³·l®`¥Lªº¦D¨Æ¼f°T¤§¸·¡AÁÙ¬OÀ³¸Ó¦p¦¹Áæ¦Ó¤£±Ë¡C²¦³º¡A³ø§i¥i¦b¼f°Tµ²§ô«á¤~¤½½Ñ©ó¥@¡C¡K¡K¦b¼f°T¥¼§¹µ²«e¡A¸Ó³ø§i«ç¼Ë¤]¤£À³¤½¶}µoªí¡C¡v¡]193B-G¡^¡]µù¤@¡^
viii.¡@¤Wz§P¨Ò¡A¹ï«ß¬F¥q´N¥»³ø§i³B²z¤èªkªº¨M©w¦³·¥°ª°Ñ¦Ò»ùÈ¡C
¡]2¡^²Ä¤GÂI¡A¬O§_¥þ±¤½¶}³ø§i¤º®e¡A¯A¤Î¦hÓ¦Ò¼{¡A¦pªÀ·|ªºª¾±¡Åv¡B¬ÛÃöªº¦D¨Æµ{§Ç¡B¨pÁôì«h¡A«O±K³d¥ôµ¥¡C¦b¨M©w¦ó®É¤Î¦p¦ó¤½¶}³ø§i¤º®e®É¡A³o¨Ç¦]¯À§¡¶·¦Ò¼{¡C¦ý¯Âºé±q¦D¨ÆÀ˱±¨¤«×¦Ò¼{¡A¦³Ãöªº³ø§i¤£¬O¥Ã¤[¤£¥i¥þ¤å¤½¶}¡C³o¯Âºé¬O®É¶¡°ÝÃD¡C¦p²×¼fªk°|©Ò¨¥¡G¡u²¦³º¡A³ø§i¥i¦b¼f°Tµ²§ô«á¤~¤½½Ñ©ó¥@¡C¡v
¡]3¡^²Ä¤TÂI¡A¦b²{¶¥¬q¡A¦³Ãö«n¤X®üÃø¨Æ¥óªº¦D¨Æ½Õ¬d¤´¦bÄ~Äò¡C¦³Ãö¤º®e§Ú¤£¯à¤½¶}¡C¦ý¦p«ß¬F¥q¦b¦«e¡]¤G¡³¤@¤T¦~¤Q¤ë¤K¤é¡^ªº·s»D¤½³ø¤¤«ü¥X¡A¡u´N®üÃø¨Æ¥ó¯A¤Îªº¦D¨Æ½Õ¬d¤u§@¤Î¤é«á¥ô¦ó¶i¤@¨B¦D¨ÆÀ˱±¡AµL½×¬O§_¯A¤Î¬F©²¤Hû¡A¥ç¤£½×¨ä¾¦ì¤§°ª§C¡A«ß¬F¥q¥²©w·|¥H¤½¥¤Î¤£°¾¤£Êªº¤âªkªÃ¤½¿ì²z¡Aµ´¤£°¾¨p¡C¡v§Ú±j½Õ¡A«ß¬F¥q¡B¦D¨ÆÀ˱±¬ì¤Î§Úµ´¤£·|¡A¥çµ´µL»¤¦]Å@µu©Î°¾¨p¡C
¡@¡@§Ú²{¦b¶i¤@¨B¸ÑÄÀ¬°¦ó«ß¬F¥q»{¬°²{¶¥¬q¥þ±¤½¶}½Õ¬d³ø§i¤º®e¡A¦³ÄY«ªº·ÀI¼vÅT¬ÛÃöªº¦D¨Æ½Õ¬d¤Î¥i¯à·|¶i¦æªº¥ô¦ó¦D¨Æµ{§Ç¡C
¡@¡@¼vÅTÃÒ¤H¡þ¶ûºÃ¤HÃҨѪº·ÀI¡G
¡]1¡^³ø§iì¤å·¥¸Ô²Ó¦a°O¿ý¤F³Q±µ¨£¤H¤h¦V¤p²Õ´£¨Ñªº®Ñ±¤Î¤fÀY³¯z¡C¦b²{¶¥¬q©ÜÅS³ø§i¥þ¤å¡A·|¥O¶ûºÃ¤H¤h¹w¥ý±oª¾ÃÒ¤Hªº³¯z¡Aµ¹¤©¥L̾÷·|¬ÛÀ³×§ï¬Æ©Î®º³y¨ä«á¦Vĵ¤è´£¨ÑªºÃÒ¾Ú¡F
¡]2¡^ÃÒ¤Hªº°O¾Ð©MÃҨѥ禳¥i¯à³QÂZ¶Ã¡Ð¥i¯à¬O»W·N¦a×§ïÃҨѥH¤Á¦X±q³ø§i¾\Ū±o¨Óªº¸ê®Æ¡A©Î¬O¼ç·NÃѦa§â¥L̥̾»¨¿W¥ß°O¾Ð©Òª¾ªº¡A»P¥LÌ·í®É¨S¦³ª¾±x¦ý¨ä«á¾\Ū±oª¾ªº¨Æ©y²V²c¡F
¡]3¡^¦³«ü¥Xĵ¤è¤w¶}©l½Õ¬d¤@¬q®É¶¡¡AÀ³¤w·|¨£¤j³¡¤ÀÃÒ¤H¡A¬G¥H¤W¬O¹L¼{¡C§Ú±j½Õĵ¤è½Õ¬d¤´¦b¶i¦æ¡A¥H¤W¤£¬O¹L¼{¡C§ó«nªº¬O¡A°£²{¶¥¬qªº¦D¨Æ½Õ¬d¥~¡A±±¤ènþÓ²´±N¨Ó¥i¯à¶i¦æªº¦D¨Æ¼f°T¡CÃÒ¤H¦b®x¤WªºÃÒ¨¥¤~¬O³Ì«nÃÒ¾Ú¡CÃÒ¤H¶·±N¥L©Òª¾¡B©Ò°O±o¡B©Ò¸g¾úªº§i¶Dªk®x¡A¤£¬O¥L±q¨ä¥L§÷®ÆÅª¨Óªº¸ê®Æ¡C«áªÌ¬O¡u¶Ç»DÃҨѡv¡A°£¬Y¨Ç¨Ò¥~±¡ªp¡A¤£³Qªk®x±µ¯Ç¡CYÃÒ¤H±N¥L¥»¨°O¾Ð©Òª¾¤Î¸g¾úªº¡A»P¥LÌ·í®É¨S¦³ª¾±x¦ý¨ä«á¾\Ū±oª¾ªº¨Æ©y²V²c¡A¥L̪ºÃҨѪº¤À¶q©M¥i¾a©Ê¡A¬Æ¦Ü¥i±µ¯Ç©Ê¡A§¡·|¨ü¨ì¤£§Qªº¼vÅT¡A§ÚÌþÓ²´±N¨Ó¥ô¦ó¦D¨ÆÀ˱±¼f°T¤¤¥i¯àµo¥Íªº¨Æ±¡¡F
¡]4¡^¤Wzªº¦Ò¼{µ´¤£¬O¦M¨¥ÁqÅ¥¡C¯S§O¡AY±±¸o¯A¤Î¦h¦~«eµo¥Íªº¨Æ¡AÃÒ¤H°O¾Ðªº¥i¾a©Ê¤×¬°ÃöÁä¡CY«ß¬F¥q²{¦b¤£ÂÔ·V¦a³B²z³o°ÝÃD¡A·|ª½±µ¬°ÅG¤è¦b±N¨Ó¥ô¦ó¬ÛÃöªº¦D¨Æ¼f°T¤¤¡A´£¨Ñ°ò¦¤Î²z¾Ú¡A½L°Ý¨Ã½èºÃÃÒ¤H¨Ñµüªº¥i¾a©Ê¡C
¡@¡@¼vÅT±N¨Ó¥i¯à¥X²{ªº¦D¨Æ¼f°Tªº¤½¥©Êªº·ÀI¡G
¡]1¡^§Ú¤£¥i©ÜÅSĵ¤è½Õ¬d²Ó¸`¡A¦ý¡u¤½Â¾¤Hû¦æ¬°¥¢·í¸o¡v¬O¤@Ó¦ÛµMªº½Õ¬d¤è¦V¡CÄY«ªº¹H¬ö¦æ¬°¤w¥i¯àºc¦¨¡u¤½Â¾¤Hû¦æ¬°¥¢·í¸o¡v¡C¦pªG¤p²Õ³ø§iªº¤º®e»Pĵ¤è¨ä¤¤¤@Ó«ÂI½Õ¬d¤è¦V¤@¼Ë¡A±¡ªp»P¤Wz²×¼fªk°|ªº®×¨Ò«K·¥¬Ûªñ¡C¤½¶}³ø§i¥þ¤å¥i¤ÞPÅG¤è©áÀ»¡AºÙ³¼fû¥i¯à¨ü¨ì½Õ¬dªºµ²ªG©M«ØÄ³¼vÅT¡A¥O¥i¯à·|¶i¦æªº¥ô¦ó¦D¨ÆÀ˱±µ{§ÇÅܱo¤£¤½¡C¤Wz²×¼fªk°|ªº®×¨Ò¬O¤@Ó¯u¹ê¨Ò¤l¡F
¡]2¡^¤½¶}³ø§i¥þ¤å¥i¯à¼vÅTÃÒ¤H¦b®x¤WÃҨѪº¤À¶q©M¥i¾a©Ê¡A¬Æ¦Ü¥i±µ¯Ç©Ê¡C¤W¤å¤w¸ÑÄÀ¡A¤£ÂØ¡F
¡]3¡^¦³«ü¥i¤½¶}¤p²Õ«ØÄ³³B¤À¤Hûªº¦W¦r¡A¦Ó³o°µªk»Pĵ¤è¤½¶}³Q®·¤H¤h¦W¦r¤@¼Ë¡C¦ý¨ä¹ê³o¨âºØ°µªk¤£¥i¬Û´£¨Ã½×¡C¤½¶}¤p²Õ»{¬°¬Y¤H¹H¬öªºµ²½×¡A»P°õªk¾÷ºc¤½¶}³Q®·ÃhºÃ¯A®×¤H¤hªº¨¤À¡A©Ê½è¨Ã¤£¬Û¦P¡C¤@¯ë¦Ó¨¥¡A°õªk¾÷ºc¥u·|¦b´x´¤¨¬°÷ÃҾڱĨú©ë®·¦æ°Ê©M¦b¦Ò¼{¹L·|§_¼vÅT¥¼§¹¦¨ªº¦D¨Æ½Õ¬d«á¡A¤~·|¦b¦æ°Ê®i¶}«á¤½¶}³Q®·¤Hªº¨¤À¡A¦Ó«D¥u¦bÂê©w³¡¤À©Î¥þ³¡¦³¶ûºÃªº¥Ø¼Ð¤Hª«®É¡A«K¥ß§Y§â¥L̪º¨¤À¤½¶}¡C¦b¯A¤Î·G¬F¤½¸pªº½Õ¬d¡A¦b¬Y¨Ç¨Æ¥óµo¥Í«e¡]¦p©ë®·¡^¡A¬ªÅS³Q¬d¤H¤hªº¨¤À§ó¥iºc¦¨¦D¨Æ¸o¦æ¡C§Ú¸É¥R¡A¦b»P³ø§i¬ÛÃöªº¦D¨Æ½Õ¬d¤¤¡Aĵ¤è¨Ã¥¼¥¿¦¡©ë®·¥ô¦ó¤H¡F
¡]4¡^¥ç¦³«ü¥i¤½¶}¤@¨Ç¸ê®Æ¤Î¼Æ¾Ú¡A¦p¤p²Õ«ØÄ³³B¤À¤H¤hªºÃþ§O¡B¼Æ¥Ø¡B¹H¬ö©Ê½èµ¥¡C¦ý¤@¥¹¤½¶}¸Óµ¥¸ê®Æ¤Î¼Æ¾Ú¡A¥O¤H®e©ö°ò©ó¤wª¾©Î¤w¤½¶}ªº¸ê®Æ¡]¥]¬A¡m2012¦~10¤ë1¤é«n¤X®qªþªñ¼²²î¨Æ¬G½Õ¬d©eû·|³ø§i¡n©Ò¸ü¥H©¹¦U®É¬q¤£¦P¤H¤hªº³d¥ô¡^±Àºâ¥X¦³Ãö¤H¤h¨¤À¡A¹ï¸¹¤J®y¡A¾ÉP»Pª½±µ©ÜÅS¦³Ãö¤H¤h¨¤À±a¨Ó¤@¼Ëªº¤£¤½¡C
¡]5¡^§Ú¥ç§Æ±æ´£¥X¡A¡m2012¦~10¤ë1¤é«n¤X®qªþªñ¼²²î¨Æ¬G½Õ¬d©eû·|³ø§i¡nªº©Ê½è»P¤p²Õ³ø§i¤£¦P¡C½Õ¬d©eû·|ªº¥Øªº¤£¬O¨M©w¯A¨Æ¤Hªº¦D³d©Î¥Á³d¡A¦ÓÅ¥ÃÒµ{§Ç¬O¤½¶}ªº¡F¬Û¤Ï¡A¤p²Õ½Õ¬d¨ä¤@«ÂI¬O´M§ä¯Ê¥¢¡A¨Ã¹ï¦³Ãö¤Hû«ØÄ³¬ö«ß¦æ°Ê¡A¦Ó·jÃÒµ{§Ç¨Ã¤£¬O¤½¶}¶i¦æ¡A¦ý³ø§iì¤å«o¸Ô²Ó¦a¦C¥X³Q±µ¨£¤H¤h¦V¤p²Õ´£¨Ñªº³¯z¡C¥t¥~¡A¤p²Õªº½Õ¬d½d³ò¤ñ·í¦~ªº½Õ¬d©eû·|Áï¡A¥ç»P¡u¤½Â¾¤Hû¦æ¬°¥¢·í¸o¡v³o¥i¯àªº¦D¨Æ½Õ¬d¤è¦V§¹¥þ«Å|¡C§Ú̦³³d¥ô¹ï¤£¦Pªº½Õ¬d³ø§i¦]À³¤£¦P®É¶¡¡BÀô¹Ò©M»Ýn¿W¥ß¦Ò¶q¡C
¡@¡@³Ì«á¡A§Ú§Æ±æ«¥Ó¡A§Ú²z¸Ñ¤½²³ªº´Á±æ¤Î®aÄݪº¤ß±¡¡C¦ý«ß¬F¥q¤Î§Úªº³d¥ô¡A¬OºÉ¯à¤O«O»Ù¦D¨Æ¼f°T¤½¥¿¡F³oÂI¡A¹ï©ó»´äªkªvªÀ·|¡A·¥¬°«n¡C§Ú©Ó¿Õ¡A«ß¬F¥q·|¦b¦D¨Æ½Õ¬d¤Îµ{§Ç¨ì¹F¤£¦P¶¥¬q®É¡AºÉ§Ö«·s¼fµø¥þ±¤½¶}³ø§iªº¨M©w¡A¨Ã¦V¤j®a¥æ¥N¡C
µù¤@¡Gì¤å¬°¡u... The spectacle of a Financial Secretary pressing for publication and calling a press conference to publicise the report, knowing that a prosecution was intended but willingly taking the risk that the trial might be prejudiced is unedifying ... The notion that this was in aid of governmental transparency does not bear examination. Such transparency is laudable, but no one could reasonably suggest that it should be pursued at the risk of prejudicing a person's criminal trial on a serious charge. Publication could in any event have taken place after the trial. ... The report should never have been published before the trial was over.¡v
§¹
¢±¢¯¢°¢³¦~¢³¤ë¢±¢·¤é¡]¬P´Á¤@¡^
»´ä®É¶¡¢°¢¶®É¢¯¢²¤À